Monday, May 9, 2016

Laura: Conceptual vs. Experimental Innovation

So, as an innovator, are you more like Albert Einstein or Martin Luther King?   

It's not as strange a question as you might think. We've been talking this week about the book "Originals: How Non-Conformists Move the World", by Adam Grant.  Today we pick up Grant's discussion of how new ideas actually come about.

While we all have the image of new ideas arriving as a bolt of lightning, many innovations are the result of years of experimentation.  I bet you can think of examples of each kind. 

On one hand, Einstein's key insight into the theory of special relativity came from a burst of inspiration.  He was riding on a streetcar and thinking about what would happen if his train travelled at the speed of light.  (Something that I admit is NOT what I am thinking about when I'm on Amtrak.)  This thought problem triggered an insight, and while Einstein remained creative throughout his career, Grant reports that toward the end of his life, Einstein actually struggled with accepting new ideas, like quantum physics.  So that is one model of the creativity, the conceptual innovator, well known by the signature "Eureka!"  moment.

This is in contrast to Experimental Innovators, who "Test and Learn."  In an example that I've never seen unpacked before, Grant uses Martin Luther King's approach to writing the "I Have a Dream" speech as an example of how years of speaking about civil rights led to the creativity and one-of-a-kind impact of Dr. King's words: 

"Despite being just thirty-four when he gave his "dream" speech, it was his twentieth year of speaking publicly about civil rights.  At fifteen, he made the state finals for delivering an original speech on civil rights".  

Is there any greater way to refine your approach than twenty years of struggling to convince numerous audiences?  Clearly, it was a long road that led to the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, and a true innovator who spoke to the nation that day.

In virtually every field, experience informs innovation.  Experimentation is the backbone of scientific discovery.  Even Picasso said "Learn the rules like a pro, so you can break them like an artist."  You get the feeling that Picasso knew just which rules to break to give his art the jolt of the new.

So, are you looking for a Eureka moment, or using your experience to gain new insight?  It looks like, either way, you are in very good company. 


- Laura